“We are all working together to make something really good for all of us; they will be looking at us from all over because we are on the verge of something historic.”

These were some of the comments at Wednesday night’s special meeting of the Mayor and Council to give all interested parties  still another opportunity ask questions, get answers and give opinions on the proposed Pre-K-12 regionalization proposal for this borough, Henry Hudson Regional, Atlantic Highlands and Sea Bright.

Professionals from the Porzio office, Kerry Wright and Vito Gagliardi were at the meeting to answer any questions and to explain the financial aspects, board makeup and procedures that would be the future should voters approve it through a public question. Atlantic Highlands Mayor and Council has the resolution on their agenda at Thursday’s meeting to ask the Commissioner of Education if regionalization for the three boroughs can be put on the ballot in November. Both Highlands and Sea Bright adopted similar resolutions several months ago.

Mayor Carolyn Broullon said already meetings are scheduled, including one Thursday afternoon, among board members borough administrators, school officials including Dr Tara Beams and council members to move ahead with discussions on the specific question that would be on the November ballot.

Gagliardi said should Atlantic Highlands approve the resolution at their meeting, a single resolution, also approved by the three boards of education would then go to the Education Commissioner for permission for the ballot.  The resolution would include the wording for the question that would appear on the ballot.  He estimated the Commissioner would have a decision back to the boroughs within a few weeks, given her advanced knowledge the towns have been working on that possibility.  That would leave sufficient time to meet the Aug. 14 deadline to have the question on the November ballot.

Bouillon said at the beginning of the meeting that many questions concerning a new structure would be explained by the professionals during the meeting. And they were.

If regionalization is approved in November, he estimated that if the school boards and administrators could complete all their portions of the new plan, regionalization could be in place by July 2023, in time for the start of the 2023-2024 school year.

A new school board of education would be formed, a nine member board made up of four members from each Highlands and Atlantic Highlands, and one member form Sea Bright. The original new board would be comprised of representatives from each of the current boards, with Sea Bright naming its single representative inasmuch as they currently do not have a board of education. Elections after the formation would be held every year, establishing staggered three year terms.

Nor will there be any difference in how the individual borough’s taxes for school purposes are determined, Gagliardi said. Currently, the assessed valuation of each town together with the number of students in the school system are both used to determine the tax percentage for each borough. Broullon pointed out that current figures show Highlands has an increased assessed valuation of 14 percent in 2022, Atlantic Highlands has a 10 per cent increased valuation, and Sea Bright 12 percent. The figures change every year, because of students in the schools and assessed valuations, and that same formula in place now would continue under the new regionalization.

All three boroughs must approve the regionalization question by a majority vote, Gagliardi said, before the tri town PreK-12regionalizaation can be approved.

Gagliardi also pointed out that the regionalization and its operation is so structured that no town’s savings could drop by more than 20 per cent and both Highlands and Atlantic Highland will recognize and receive substantial savings immediately based on current figures. In response to Atlantic highlands Councilman Brian Boms, Gagliardi said the boroughs will experience “at least a healthy six figure savings every year.” He pointed out that Sea Bright’s costs would be higher in the beginning but ultimately they too would recognize substantial savings similar to Highlands and Atlantic Highlands.

With fewer than 30 people present for this, the second presentation by the professionals who conducted the study for the three towns,  there was an air of positive thinking and accomplishment that “we are working together to make something really good happen for all of us,” as Broullon said. Her remarks were echoed by former Highlands Board of Education member Patricia Robertson who said, “finally it looks like we are moving forward,” citing newspaper accounts of how many times the local boards have studied, or proposed study of a more economic regional district, but nothing was ever accomplished.

Atlantic Highlands resident Eileen Cusick asked for and received assurance that educators are already in the talking and planning stages for the successful integration of the Sea Bright students into a new environment, and urged that attention to the students be strongly considered.  The plan allows for Sea Bright parents to make the choice of whether they want their students to continue in their present transportation to Oakhurst and Shore Regional High School or begin their next school year in the new regional plan.

The Highlands Mayor and Council has called a special meeting  at 6:30 p.m. Tonight, Wednesday, June 8 to give all individuals the opportunity to learn more about the Regionalization of Highlands, Atlantic Highlands and Sea Bright in a K-12 school district.

The meeting will be held in the Robert Wilson community Center on Snug Harbor Avenue.

Attendees will be given an opportunity to give their input on the Regionalization.

NO formal action will be taken at the meeting which will be run to ensure as many interested persons as possible have the opportunity to be heard and ask questions, in order to ensure an orderly meeting and allow adequate time for the public to be heard.

Unfortunately, the meeting is not planned to be broadcast via Zoom or other electronic platform

Just read the great article in the Atlantic Highlands Herald written by the three Democrat members of the borough council, Jon Crowley, Lori Hohenleitner and Brian Dougherty.

Sorry I cannot include it in VeniVidiScripto as well since they did not send it to me to publish.

However, it is a great read, and gave a great description of events on regionalization up until this time, hinted at whether Sea Bright would be included now or later, and strangely enough, did not think the Borough Council should have a meeting to explain the Porzio report they paid for, like the other two towns did.

Their reason is because they…the three council members, found the Porzio report moot, in spite of that group being the only one in the state to plan a successful regionalization plan elsewhere. And in spite of the borough paying for the study and not holding a workshop so all the people of the borough could make their own decision.

It all reminded me of an article from the Red Bank Register back in 1988, at about this same time of year. That article was written by Kenny Trainor, another terrific reporter with whom I covered dozens of council meetings in many towns. We worked alongside Mark Magyar, another very intelligent and thoughtful reporter who is now Director of the Sweeney Center for Public Policy and an ace on state government and state news.

Mark had left the Register when Kenny drafted this story, and was reporting for the Hackensack Record, before moving on to be state house reporter and an editor for the Asbury Park Press, a position he held for a few years in the early 1990s before going on to edit the NJ Spotlight and be a campaign strategist, lecturer, and many other wonderful things prior to his present position.

He’s been vitally important in this regionalization question for the Bayshore towns and certainly knows his stuff.

But back to Kenny’s story… He wrote about a meeting of the Henry Hudson, Atlantic Highlands and Highlands school boards to discuss “the pros and cons of combining their school districts.”  It was 1988, 34 years ago.

Then Schools Superintendent Milt Hughes told the board there were some problems with how the district was situated then, saying, “first off, you have multiple bodies making policy decisions instead of a single body.” He listed all the duplication , lack of flexibility in organization, and some other disadvantages of their school boards, three districts.  He advised the boards to “take a good hard look” at the aspects and devise a sample budget based on combining the costs of all three.

Frank Teeple of Highlands was the school board chairman at Henry Hudson then, and told each of the boards to “go back and think about whether you want to go ahead with a study.” … 34 years ago.

The board said they would and would make a  decision about whether they would conduct a study by the next tri-board meeting.

There aren’t any newspaper accounts in 1988 or 1989 on whatever that decision was.

Nor was Hudson the only school district grappling with the question. Rumson Fair Haven is similar, and they were opposed to combining their elementary schools in the regional district, in spite of the additional cost of having more school boards.

Throughout the state, actually, in many parts of the nation, numerous school districts goaded by taxpayers complaining about the high cost and waste in the education field, were discussing the same thing. But little was done.

We’re now 34 years later.  Thursday night there is a resolution on the Atlantic Highlands council table calling for sending the idea of K-12 regionalization to the Commissioner of Education, a necessary step in order to let the people vote.

That’s a positive thing. Let’s hope the resolution is passed. Unanimously. And let’s further hope the questions that will now come up get resolved, answered, and enable the folks to see a question on regionalization on the November ballot so they can decide what cost education.  Let’s hope it’s done in time for November, without incurring extra costs for a special election next year.